dan-843-657853 The title is taken from the male protagonist of the original novel, but the screenplay changes the opening and closing to the viewpoint of one of the female characters. The central portion still features the two male characters, but we never find out what happened to them. I think this is why reviewers found the ending unsatisfying.It has an all-star cast with young up and coming actors and Kenji Sawada grown much more rotund than his younger idol days. It is reputed to be Takashi Miike's first jidaigeki period film.Technical type comment. I own two copies of this film. The ArtsMagic copy has a very good "making of film" bonus that is English subtitled. This is all too rare for Japanese films. It also has subtitled interviews with the director and cast. But sadly the transfer of the feature film is much too dark. I didn't see anything in the background, some sets are very dimly lit, and it made for a rather dreary viewing experience. I suppose the darkness suits the Dickensian nature of the story. The disc bonus menu has annoying mismatch between the titles and the place to point your cursor. A few years later, I bought a Chinese-made high-bit copy and when I viewed it I was amazed to see much more detail in the background. It much improved the viewing experience. So you need to see both to optimize experience of this Miike film. I do not own a Japan-made copy, but it could be the best of all.

Polaris_DiB You know, not only have I never seen a Takashi Miike movie quite like this, in some ways this movie is different than any other Japanese movie I've ever seen as well. It shares conceits closer to Mexican cinema and melodrama than Japanese drama styles and Miike's themes. And of course, still, it is a very Miike movie.Because of the fast and continual production of his oeuvre, Takashi Miike films can sometimes look like the cheaply produced videos they are and have a very thrown-together editing, but that has never been a problem for him because his style and sensibilities have vastly outweighed his production values, like any good independent and maverick filmmaker. Later movies of his look better and are better crafted, but this earlier work is noteworthy because he slows it down a bit and fills the story with gorgeous, every-frame's-a-still-picture-for-a-gallery imagery. From the opening shot of a hanging woman to the burning building to the closing, this movie is very visually pleasant to watch.It's also a somewhat strange story. Sabu is a young man tortured with guilt and grief for his friend Eiji, who was sent to a worker's jail after being framed for stealing gold cloth. Eiji is much more patient and in control, planning his vengeance as he fights off the low-lifes in the jail and protects the weaker inmates. What's interesting about that is that the title character is actually incredibly melodramatic and inactive, which is not typical in most narratives. Eiji, the more dynamic and interesting character, would be a much more appropriate name for the movie; Sabu is more a supporter.Still, Miike isn't one to get caught up on narrative theory, preferring instead to take it where he may. This is actually a much more sober and patient Miike than many of his fans may be used to, but still contains his trademark violence and style--only now the "excesses" are put into the cinematography and background instead of the action. Another good film by another continually amazing auteur.--PolarisDiB

Marc Ferriere This is a really instructive example of the directorial skills that Takishi Miike exhibits in most of his films. His abilities are often lost on many viewers because they're too infatuated with cowheads, necrophilia, and bazookas. A coherent, dramatically-charged jidaigeki like this might challenge the patience and attention spans of some Miike-devotees. There are long stretches of this film that feature two characters facing one another and speaking. Being more plot-driven than action-driven, I can see how some might be bored to death, but it's this more cerebral pacing that highlights the kind of mastery that Miike is capable of. This movie should go a long way towards silencing critics who accuse him of being too dependant on yakuza mayhem and the usual clichés (bestiality, scat, necrophilia, homosexual rape, mutilation, etc.) That being said, this is a competent period film that stands on it's own. It is only slightly apparent to the viewer that it was made for television - it really has all the trappings of a regular film (casting & sets). All of the actors nail their performances and the "making of" featurette included on the R1 DVD shows the care and commitment that went into producing it.

Simon Booth First things first, this isn't a Samurai movie as it is sometimes advertised. It's a period film set in the time of the Samurai, but the main characters are just normal folk. I might also mention that despite the film being named after the character Sabu, it spends almost the whole time focussed on his friend Eiji (played by Tatsuya Fujiwara of Battle Royale fame).It's hard to recognise the influence of director Takashi Miike here, as it features none of his usual over-the-top madness. However, it's another film that shows the director to be capable of far more than just shocking the audience with violence.However, I still reckon it amongst the weakest of 20 or so Miike films that I've seen. As a drama it's quite well made, but I was left largely unmoved by it. I wasn't quite sure what message or feeling I was meant to take away, and after 2 hours I felt that I still didn't really know or understand the characters that well. It felt like we were just getting part of a larger story, and what we glimpsed wasn't enough to fully appreciate it.That said, it was nice to see Tatsuya Fujiwara in a non-Battle Royale setting, though the film indicates as one might expect from one so young that his acting really isn't that great without Kinji Fukasaku and a strong screenplay behind him.Overall, I feel that it's a film I could have appreciated more if I'd known up front what it was about (no Samurai!), but that I don't expect to watch again any time soon to find out.