HeatherHarris16 The pilot for this show was greatly done! I could not have been more pleased with everything about it! After watching the show and finding out that the CW did not want to run the series I was greatly disappointed! The director/producer/writer did EVERYTHING right with this show, and there would have been PLENTY of fans watching the show week after week!! This show had so much to offer to the viewers. Everything about it was perfect. The first episode made me crave to watch more and more. I liked it so much that I watched it a few times already since last month. The casting in this show was amazing. I actually prefer to see Justin Hartley as AquaMan in this series then as The Green Arrow in Smallville.

Skellator Aquaman a.k.a. Mercy Reef sucks! Don't know where where these good reviews are coming from, mass hysteria maybe? Acting isn't bad, Ving Rhames is the stand out but the lines the writers have them saying are dreadful, and the exposition is simply pathetic. The scene introducing the obvious love interest, Lt. Torres, made me laugh it was so bad. "These orders come from way above my head" (what, to do a flyover?) "This is not the LPGA Torres, you tee off with the men!" Glad it wasn't picked up for a series, from the same folk that brought you Smallville but nowhere near as good.Watch it if you want to see how not to make a TV show.

Liam Merrigan Being a long time fan of all which is remotely related to the comic book genre, i feel this has the potential to be as good as Smallville (which in my opinion is one of the best shows on TV today). Justin Hartley makes a good Aquaman much better than the smallville actor, the show has suspense, excitement and has the appeal which makes a viewer want to keep watching time and time again, i would be greatly disappointed if CW or any other television company did not pick it up. It should be and hopefully CW will realise the attention just 1 episode is getting and air it. I think it was a good move from Apple to be able to download this from i- tunes, this grabs peoples attention. Another reason why i would like to see Aquaman on TV is because i don't know how much more they will be able to do with Smallville.

salvy182 Wow, I really enjoyed this show! The acting, story and effects were great. The cast seemed to work well together, it's too bad that Justin Hartley is now on Smallville. For a pilot, the show was great and showed a LOT of potential! Wow, what was the CW thinking by not picking it up?! The pilot had action, mystery sex appeal. People were expecting great things from this show and the CW screwed it up without even getting it on the air. They're crazy. Hopefully the huge success and huge number of downloads on i Tunes will make them change their minds... hopefully. With an average rating of 4 and a half stars, I don't know what CW is waiting for!