lavatch The shortcomings of this well-produced, twelve-part series lie primarily in the selection of commentators. It was not clear why celebrities were selected over scholars, but the choice came back to bite the filmmakers. Martha Stewart, Brian Williams, Tom Brokaw, and David Petraeus have all had their careers besmirched since the series was released. The main point is that they did not provide stellar insights into U.S. history. And neither did Michael Douglas or Meryl Streep!The major strength of the episodes were the dynamic use of computer graphic images. Such technological achievements as the building of the Erie Canal, skyscrapers like New York's Flatiron Building, and the construction of Hoover Dam were brilliantly recreated. The best programs were those of the early history of the nation, leading up to the Civil War. But after 1860s, the events were telescoped into superficial capsules. A glaring omission was the progressive movement in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The closing segments focused far too much on scientific and cultural history (suburbia, computer revolution, NASA) at the expense of social and political events. For viewers who enjoyed these programs, there is a beautifully written book by Kevin Brown that is a companion to the series. The twelve-chapter book dovetails closely with the episodes and offers more detailed coverage of the topics. This series is briskly paced and dynamically narrated by Liev Schreiber. While it may be slanted in the area of "feel good" propaganda, it nonetheless covers the basics of American history. One of the most interesting touches was the occasional commentary from Donald J. Trump, which was delivered at a time when he did not have presidential aspirations. One of his most interesting points was that to succeed in America takes not merely perseverance, but also brains-an assertion that is borne out in the coverage of the great entrepreneurs covered in the series.

edh-thwacker First, there are no factual errors. You can check this stuff in a text book. But the 1849 gold is in the provocative interpretation and connections this series makes! History is two things: facts (black and white, easy to check), and then on top of this, the story and interpretation of a national experience. That's awesome and wholly subjective! (Has the question of what caused the Civil War ever been resolved? I think not! Never will be!!! :-) ). And why not hear from the chords of Sheryl Crow and Michael Douglas? Would Professor Such-and-such from Unknown University be any better? (Although there is plenty of input from the likes of David Baldacci, Henry Louis Gates/Harvard Emeritus, and Colin Powell). My family, we know the facts. This series took us to the next level of discussion and lively debate.

yoanag As a teacher, I am using the first two episodes to help fifth grade students understand and appreciate the challenges of the American Revolution. I will admit I have not watched beyond these episodes, but feel that at least the first two give an abbreviated but accurate window about the challenges of the American Revolution. I would have liked to see more about the French and Indian Wars, as well as the Stamp Act and Intolerable Acts, but there are few videos available that open the many topics of interest about the American Revolution without being COMPLETELY boring. This video, in my opinion, will interest students to research beyond what they have seen on screen. Sadly, the youth of today need a video to motivate them to learn more, so I feel this video series does a nice job of making the American Revolution interesting and accessible to young people.

SantaClause One person here doesn't like the show because he/she disagrees with the politics of some of the people narrating.A few others don't like it because things are left out.Some don't like the way things were interpreted.The goal of the show is to keep it exciting and give a brief overview of what what happened. Of course there's going to be a lot left out. Of course there's a lot to be left to interpretation.It's not a perfect show, but it does give a glimpse of events by adding dramatization. Lots of things have to be left out for a show like this.Overall, 8/10.