Nick Dets The best scenes of "Black Circle Boys" are of the film's wounded teenagers reacting to their turbulent lives in total isolation. The main character Kyle is a young man with a weak personal identification, mostly likely stemming from the distant relationship he has with his parents. Writer-director Matthew Carnahan allows these revelations to happen periodically and inductively. He directs such scenes in long takes, relying completely on the performances and nuance of the barren surroundings to bring forth the tensions boiling below the story's surface.These few scenes are peppered in an otherwise flawed film which is melodramatic, implausible and disappointingly underdeveloped - giving the film a mysterious emotional undertone it doesn't follow through on. The opening introduces Kyle and his All-American swimming buddies wreaking antisocial havoc on the top of a building. Carnahan uses the POV of a videocamera, but stages the action awkwardly - rendering the whole approach of the scene useless. One pivotal detail in particular is extremely obscured, and that is the accidental death of one of Kyle's best friend who apparently falls off of the building.The movie shifts into Kyle's new life in a new town and school. It becomes a traditional juvenile delinquency teen pic, throwing trite plot elements seen in most similar films from "Rebel Without a Cause" to "The Craft." Inevitably Kyle falls in with the bad kids, which in this case is a group of headbanging metal thrashers who call themselves the Black Circle Boys. Its leader Shane (Eric Mabius) is uncompromising, sociopathic, and slitheringly persuasive. The Black Circle boys turn out to be more than a fledgling metal band, and Kyle finds himself uncontrollably immersed in dangerous occult rituals and violent antisocial escapades.The familiarities and annoyances of the film are largely to the fault of the script. While the style could have been glossy and dull like most teen pics of the time, it transcends the disappointing story with an unsettling conjunction of hand-held cinematography and gritty art direction. Carnahan's direction is raw in a way few teen films were in 1997, because he meets the material with at least attempted realism and a very serious tone. However. he's not consistently on his game throughout the film, and some scenes are bogged down from lazy direction.The film is helped by a consistent and believable performance by Scott Bairstow. He is brooding, but likable and draws understanding to a character who makes progressively bad decisions. This is a weak, but all-around watchable teen drama that was a precursor to the realistic teen dramas of the 2000's, like "L.I.E.," "Bully" or "Mean Creek."

waterlily1002 As a youthful fan of the Lost Boys, I actually liked Matthew's movie. It was not a big budget "hollywood" production movie, but the story was very good. I am 33 and still remember what it feels like to be the "new" kid in school and having to "prove" yourself. Kids can be mean, especially teenagers. But as a 33 year old with a 16 year old punk mentality still, I can relate to the story line. Not on a witchcraft level, even though everyone in high school thought we were witches because we wore black and pointy shoes. Just remember what it felt like to be an "outcast" or not a popular kid and I think you will enjoy showing your kids this movie and watching it with your angst ridden "adult" friends. Also, real life stories have a way of paralleling "reality". Where do you think "reality TV" came from? If you are looking for fabulous effects, look some place else. This is just a good story about "some boy's life". Give the story a chance and I think you will enjoy it. Wow, I was just told that I had to put 10 lines of text down. I am not known to be short winded. OK, Matthew Carnahan is an amazing man too.

skyynyteataol When I first watched this movie I thought it was some sort of joke. Turns out it wasn't. If your a Marilyn Manson fan, you'll love it. If you understand what i'm getting at, don't waste your frikken time. The only thing worse that this was Mr. Mabius' attempt at portraying the crow... =(

L_Santinha This must have been one of the worst films I have ever seen, even Titanic has better acting than this...Anyone who thinks about watching this movie:don´t do this to yourself, it were the most boring two hours of my life!!! It is not only the acting, also the image given of the Gothic Movement is absolutely exaggerated. This movie should be on the index!!!!!!!!!