patriciatobin48 I bought this DVD because I am a huge fan of David Boreanaz and found it quite entertaining and a pleasant surprise. Monica Potter is a good actress but I didn't feel she was powerful enough for this film. The male actors were all very good and the idea behind the film was good but it lacked cohesion. David was, as always, excellent but as with the other actors, their potential characters were not explored enough. However it was a pleasant light-hearted little film which did not discredit any of the actors. However, unfortunately this is a film which will be seen by a limited audience. I think it would be a good made-for-TV movie rather than the cinema. As a David Boreanaz fan I would prefer him to have meatier roles than these pretty-boy roles he seems to have been offered. The man is an accomplished actor who can do action, romantic and tragic roles and I'd like to see him in more productive parts. Anthony LaPaglia as always was a joy to watch.

huh I caught this movie on cable. I had hopes for it because the idea appeared fun.I also was looking forward to Gael in an English speaking role. He was reduced to a stereotype. It would have been fun had they had him play the scientist and the Buffy actor (not David Boreneaz) play the playwrite. Go against type and show some imagination.Monica Potter is a beautiful woman. However, the character of Lucy whined too much, was not kind nor did she inspire us to care for her. It was also surprising that she ended up with the 'nice guy' as he certainly was a lot more likable than her. At the end of the day, this movie re-enforces the idea that men will put up with just about any kind of behavior from a beautiful woman if they see even a glimmer of an opportunity to get laid.

httpmom Didn't expect much from this movie but it actually turned out to be a kind of darling idea. The plot managed to squeeze into a one year period the range of pre-marriage men most of us spend years inevitably dating before we get smart enough to realize what makes a guy Mr. Right. And I must say if I have to look at one more movie with Julie Roberts or that even sappier, Meg Ryan in it I give up on romantic comedy all together! So this leading lady seemed such a refreshing breath of air. Monica Potter is like Julia R. only way sweeter, a zillion times more original and a lot more realistic. I decided to watch this picture with my daughter because we both just adore David Boreanaz from ‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer' and ‘Angel' fame.As I am sure you guessed by now... this is...without a doubt...a chick flick. The kind of which would do the ‘WE' channel proud. That said, I really enjoyed the men in the film. All of them worked well at enabling us to picture how certain choices have the power to change our lives forever. The `dates` were also amusing because they were each unique. You could easily imagine how the heroin's life would be altered by which one she would ultimately pick as a husband. It was slightly trippy to realize*SPOILER FOLLOWS*Mr. Right was a grownup Henry Thomas whom I had not seen since his priceless performance as the adorable Elliott in E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982). Also worth noting that Julie Christie does a remarkable entertaining and out of character performance as Lucy's mom.While I would never need to own this movie...it's a good one night stand...as it were.

floramenzies If you love romantic comedies, this is definitely for you, and if you don't like them, this might just convert you! I'm with a Lucy has a refreshingly original concept, because it is totally unlike typical romcoms, as there aer 5 potential leading men instead of 1! Lucy is a newly single girl who is still unhappy after being dumped by her seemingly perfect boyfriend in a lift. Over the course of the year, pushed on by her sister and best friend, she goes on 5 blind dates. It is revealed at the beginning of the movie that she is marrying one of the dates.The film is about the 5 dates she goes on, and it is not revealed until the end who she marries, so it is thankfully not all predictable like so many of films of thid type are. In fact it's such a great idea, I'm surprised no one thought of it before! This is totally uplifiting, funny and really sweet film, and not at all pretentious or silly or irritating. Potter is great and not at all annoying as you might expect from some comedy actresses, as in this film she is a bright, witty and wise girl, and all the men are great, what a brilliant range of men all in 1 film. Even guys might like it! Please see this, you will pleasantly surprised and uplifted. It's just a shame you can't buy it in England!