Steffi_P It says something for the strength of a story when it can be made twice and still be just as good second time round. Remakes are usually odious things, second-rate bastardisations of a sacred classic that should never have got the green light. However when director Leo McCarey remade Love Affair in 1957 as An Affair to Remember it worked just as well as the original. The later picture has become better known, but Love Affair is still a wonderful thing in its own right.Arguably the biggest difference between the two versions is the cast. Love Affair sees Irene Dunne in what is perhaps the finest performance of her career, showing off all the varied strands of her talent. Dunne was one of the first stars who could combine a fantastic singing voice with real acting ability. When she sings she puts feeling into every note and gesture, making the songs blend seamlessly into her character's emotional development. And she could do comedy as well as the boys, often developing a ballsy rapport with her leading men as she does here with Charles Boyer. Boyer is not quite as breezily likable as Cary Grant would be in 1957 (and ironically, Grant could just as easily have played this role in 1939), but he is a strong dramatic performer and certainly fits the bill. Maria Ouspenskaya is very good too. Her role is negligible in terms of screen time but it has a bearing on the whole plot, and despite her frailty and quietness Ouspenskaya has the necessary presence to deliver a suitably memorable performance.The cast may vary, but the director is the same for both versions, and when McCarey came to do the remake he followed the original almost shot-for-shot. The implication is that his earlier work was already good enough, which it certainly is. McCarey calls upon his silent comedy background as usual, making use of long takes, subtle manoeuvres and compositions in depth. Sometimes this is as comical as it is meaningful – Dunne and Boyer sitting side-by-side at their separate tables for one is like a sight gag. Other times it is dramatically poignant. The couple's heartfelt talk on the last night of the cruise is shot in one very long take, but rather than making it completely static, the director shows us the gentle rocking of the ship as a tender counterpoint. That's typical McCarey, finding ways of keeping things moving without looking artificial or going against the mood of the scene.But perhaps the biggest secret to the dual success of the two versions is that wonderful screenplay. We have an original story by McCarey and Mildred Cram, fashioned into a screenplay by Delmer Daves and Donald Ogden Stewart. McCarey always had a nose for a heartrending love story and Stewart pretty much defined the romantic drama of the 30s and 40s. The romance develops naturally – it's not one of those misogynistic quasi-abductions you often see in movies of this period. The fateful twist is perhaps a little trite and melodramatic, but everything that comes before has been set up with such an easygoing realism that the bolt-from-the-blue is acceptable. The final resolution is just what we would expect, but it is done with a delicate simplicity that makes its impact very real. An Affair to Remember may be the better known picture, but both versions seem to fit into their own era with really very little difference between them. The reason of course is that Love Affair has that uncomplicated timelessness, which still makes it a moving experience today.

Syl Irene Dunne and Charles Boyer star in this romantic film about two potential lovers who come across on a cruise ship. First, they are magnificent and Hollywood legends. The film's been remade but I don't think it holds a candle to the original. Anyway, they travel on the ship and get to know each other. Dunne's character McKay plans to meet her Michel (played by Boyer) at the top of the Empire State Building on July 1. She describe the building as the closest to the heavens in New York City. Michel is an aspiring artist and Dunne plays an aspiring singer. Will they meet? Will something or somebody stop them? You have to wonder what the outcome will be with these two lovers? I won't spoil the story. Maria Oupenskaya does a marvelous job as Michel's grandmother. The rest of the cast is also fine but I don't recall many of their names. But this film made the Empire State Building a romantic location rather than just a tourist attraction. Still it's one of the most beautiful buildings in the world.

kenjha An American woman and a French playboy fall in love on a ship and plan to meet in six months at the Empire State Building. McCarey remade the film in 1957, a version that is much more popular, but the original is as good if not better. Dunne is fabulous as the woman, bringing more warmth and a different sensibility to the role than Deborah Kerr did in the remake. Being French and being 40 years old at the time, Boyer is better suited to the role of the playboy than a 54-year old Cary Grant in the later film. Ironically, McCarey's film previous to this, "The Awful Truth," starred Dunne and Grant. Sadly, no good prints of this film have survived, making it difficult to fully appreciate its charms.

wes-connors While on a cruise to New York, nightclub singer Irene Dunne (as Terry McKay) is attracted to debonair French painter Charles Boyer (as Michel Marnay), and he admires her back. But, Mr. Boyer is expected to meet and marry wealthy American fiancée Astrid Allwyn (as Lois Clarke). Over pink champagne and cigarettes, Ms. Dunne tells Boyer she has a boyfriend too, Lee Bowman (as Ken Bradley). Still, on a four hour stopover at Porto Santo, Madeira, Boyer introduces Dunne to grandmother Maria Ouspenskaya (as Janou), who appears to bless the Boyer-Dunne union. The reluctant pair promise to meet at the Empire State Building, after six months, to see how they feel. Dunne tells Boyer the tall structure is "the nearest thing to Heaven we have in New York." Leo McCarey's "Love Affair" had to have had viewers wondering about how its stars could get themselves involved in such a story - but, with Dunne and Boyer in the leads, you just go with the flow. In piecemeal, the film doesn't make sense; taken as a whole, it approaches something mystical. The perfect theme song "Wishing (Will Make it So)" was a major hit for Ray Eberle, singing with Glenn Miller's band; and, it was one of six "Oscar" nominations for the film. Dunne and Ms. Ouspenskaya received "Best Actress" and "Supporting Actress" consideration, and the film made the annual "Academy Awards" top ten. There are great witticisms from Dunne's dad, who famously said, "The things we like best are either illegal, immoral, or fattening." And, he drank like a fish.******** Love Affair (3/16/39) Leo McCarey ~ Irene Dunne, Charles Boyer, Maria Ouspenskaya, Lee Bowman