alexandre michel liberman (tmwest) By keeping quiet, speaking only when necessary Robert Taylor as Rio gives one of his best performances. All through the film you try to guess what he is thinking. He was adopted by the mother of Esqueda (Anthony Quinn) and Quinn loves and respects him. The real surprise is Howard Keel, who only used to do musicals, coming out so well as King Cameron, a man who is obstinate about building a cattle empire. Cameron is married to Cordelia (Ava Gardner) and as soon as she arrives in a river boat, and they go to their ranch, trouble starts because it has been burnt by Esqueda. Why did Esqueda do it? Because he knows that if he allows anybody to do well in business in that area, others will come and eventually he, who is a bandit will have to run away or be hanged. Quinn is great as Esqueda, just that makes the film worth seeing. Taylor, who was the second man to Quinn in the gang, eventually leaves him to help Keel, because deep down he knows his brother is becoming a crazy monster and unconsciously he is in love with Ava. But when she kisses him, he slaps her because he knows it is wrong. He is a torn man, with all those feelings and not knowing exactly what to do about it. Excellent film, not to be missed.

westerner357 Although it is supposed to take place in Texas, the film was actually made in Kanab, Utah, which accounts for the fact that it doesn't look a whole lot like west Texas to me.Cordelia and King Cameron (Gardner & Keel) locate to Texas after the Civil War and buy land in order to build a cattle ranch. Mexican bandit Esqueda (Quinn) along with his adopted white brother Rio (Taylor) burns down their house to send a message to other whites from moving into what he considers an intrusion of his territory.This oater is also notable for being one of the few non-singing roles Howard Keel did for MGM. He almost reminds me of a more cultured Joe Don Baker even right down to his western drawl. Gardner is being her usual dignified self and doesn't really add much here to the whole thing other than butting into the men's business.In fact, this film almost starts off as another repeat for Ava Gardner since she was in a similar love triangle with Clark Gable in LONE STAR (1952), except in this one, Taylor refuses her advances and pushes her away, not following the typical Hollywood convention of the time. Good twist on the part of director John Farrow. It adds a darker psychological dimension to the Taylor character.I also enjoyed Anthony Quinn's performance as the drunken Mexican bandit Esqueda, who cowers and sulks in his bedroom when things don't go his way. He comes across as a bitter, drunken buffoon who's obsession reaches a climax when Taylor defects to over to Keel's side, helping him build up their ranch.Quinn then takes over the town of Brownsville in order to force Taylor out into the open. It ends when Quinn & Taylor shoot and kill each other in the saloon while the wounded Keel lies nearby, no match for Quinn's earlier fast draw.Given Quinn's slightly hammy performance along with the darker psychological aspect Farrow's script gives to the Rio/Taylor character, I'm gonna give this one a 6 out of 10. It's not a keeper but it does hold my interest.

lorenellroy Set in the area around Brownsville ,Texas in the immediate post Civil War era this is a splendid if slightly over heated picture.The area is dominated by Mexican bandido Esqueda ,well played by Anthony Quinn, who with the aid of his Anglo sidekick Rio(a taciturn but effective Robert Taylor)seeks to ensure settlers do not occupy the region as he views them as a threat to the way of life he has established.Trouble arrives in the form of Howard Keel who ,with wife Ava Gardner by his side is set on resisting all attempts to drive him out of the territory.Rio is won over to the cause ,somewhat more due to the beauteous Gardner than to any principled reasons.The scene is set for the final confrontation between Rio and Esqueda in the town saloonThere are hints of a repressed sexual attraction for Taylor by Quinn in the script anticipating the theme of his role in Warlock( probably still the most grievously neglected Western classic) and the Taylor character displaying a penchent for an early version of gay chic in the clothing department underscores this The Quinn character is not a one dimensional villain-there is a reason for his stance and he displays a marked religious bentGood support from the great Jack Elam and Kurt Kaznar as the priest who takes a stand against Quinn.Gardner while beautiful was no great shakes as an actress and this together with an over stolid turn from Keel are the only real problems with the movie

Jugu Abraham Before I saw this movie, I had not heard of the director John Farrow. After some research I found that he was the father of Mia Farrow. I also found that he had good writing skills. This is apparent after you view this film closely. The lead characters are Rio (Robert Taylor) and Esqueda (Anthony Quinn) who turn out to be each others alter ego--one man slaps a woman who kisses him and the other kisses a woman before she slaps him.It's an unusual western because there is no hero--only a handsome troubled anti-hero. It is an unusual western in that Mexicans are not always painted as bad or stupid--it presents them as human beings. Even the 'bad' Esqueda has reverence for God's blessings. This probably is a result of Farrow's Catholicism as it is in the case when the priest gives the final blessings to the dead anti-hero (whose body is not shown, for some strange reason). An unusual way to end a film. Evidently Farrow espoused family values--the couple's marriage is strengthened and Rio says his adopted mother would not have approved of her son Esqueda's actions. The family bonds between Rio and Esqueda are the cornerstones of the script, with doses of Catholicism and social comments thrown in. Something tells me the film we see today is not what the director intended to show--perhaps the studios had their say. The loose editing makes one wonder what was going on.As far as performances, I think this is one of Quinn's finest unsung performances. Taylor is handsome and plays the dark anti-hero well--predictably dressed in dark colors. Ava Gardner's role is supposed to be heroic--dressed in white--but is it so simplistic to dismiss it as such. Is it a coincidence that she behaves differently when she wears pink?It is a strange and a fascinating trio--Taylor, Quinn and Gardner. Farrow had, in my view, a great chance to make a memorable film but somehow fumbled.