madeleine_swain OK it's 2011 and I'm sitting on a couch in Melbourne, Australia. I've bought a couple of series cheaply on DVD (Borders is in liquidation) and I'm playing a disc on the TV. In the room are my 7-year-old daughter, 10-year-old son, 74-year-old mother and 79-year-old father (last two visiting from England). Me? Somewhere between the others. We're all transfixed, laughing out loud and immediately sticking on another episode when one finishes. There's your proof right there. Brilliantly cast. Beautifully acted and written with wit, class and, often, surprising poignancy. If something is really good, it holds up nearly 50 years later and appeals to a generation normally more focused on YouTube, computer games and hand-held consoles. Classy and classic.

George Mainwaring Without any doubt, 'Dad's Army' the show about the efforts of the Home Guard during the Second World War is undoubtedly the greatest TV show ever made. It combined so much greatness- in scripts, acting, pathos, social snobbery and slapstick, it was just a dream of a show. Without going into great detail with the synopsis (that would be careless talk), 'Dad's Army' was about a Home Guard unit lead by Bank Manager Captain George Mainwaring (Arthur Lowe). His Seargent is the mysterious Wilson (John Le Mesurier) and his Corporal is Jones (Clive Dunn). These are in charge of Frazer, Walker, Godfrey and Pike (John Laurie, James Beck, Arnold Ridley and Ian Lavender). The shows humour came from the social snobbery between Mainwaring and Wilson, with Mainwaring constantly seeing Wilson as a threat to his power as Wilson went to public school, yet in reality Wilson had no wishes whatsoever to run the platoon Mainwaring so proudly was in charge of. There was also the enemy within, in this case the Chief of the ARP, Hodges. This also led to much of the humour.Yet the reason why 'Dad's Army' worked so well was the dream combination of the scripts and the actors. So many sitcoms have failed or not been as good as they could have been due to decent scripts but not so good actors or vice versa. Yet in 'Dads Army's' case, both were top class. The scripts were of fantastic value by Jimmy Perry and David Croft, Perry having been in the Home Guard during the war drew on past experiences. The scripts were full of great dialogue and wonderful characterisations.The cast was absolutely superb. Arthur Lowe and John Le Mesurier were an absolute dream team acting together, a superb partnership. Arthur Lowe's facial expressions were brilliant as was his comic timing, he was a master of comic timing. Le Mesurier's wonderful dreary laid back personality was also fantastic and this led to a great partnership with Lowe being totally unimpressed by Le Mesurier's casual manner. The rest of the cast were also great, Clive Dunn was fantastic as the old Butcher Jones. Dunn was a good few years younger than the man he was playing, but he brilliantly played old men, a speciality which Clive Dunn, still living, did in many shows. Then the privates were also great, John Laurie and Arnold Ridley the two oldest members of the cast were outstanding. John Laurie would look at the camera rolling his eyes, being extremely pessimistic. He knew how to capitulate an audience. A richly experienced actor when 'Dad's Army' first went out, John Laurie brought in great experience and gave the show so many laughs. Arnold Ridley as Private Godfrey who was older than John Laurie was also a brilliant character, so gentle and in my view the funniest bar Captain Mainwaring. He was so innocent, yet would come out with hilarious lines. For example in the episode 'Keep Young and Beautiful' Godfrey goes round to Frazer's dark morbid house, where he won't use electricity, he just has candles. Ridley brilliantly expresses 'I like candles. They're more romantic' Also the younger actors in it, James Beck as Private Walker and Ian Lavender as Private Pike also gave great value to the show, the former for his wheelin' and 'dealin' and the latter for his naivety. Also it's difficult to forget the support cast who were also great, such as Bill Pertwee's Hodges, Frank Williams Vicar, Edward Sinclair's Verger, Janet Davies's Mrs Pike and of course though we never see her, Elizabeth Mainwaring.The first series was something of a saga, going through a week by week progression from the platoon being formed in the first episode, to the increase of uniforms and weapons being delivered throughout the first series to finally them meeting Winstone Churchill. Then from Series 2 onwards, it was more traditional, with different situations each week.In 1973, just before the end of the sixth series, James Beck who played Private Walker sadly died aged a mere 43. His role as Walker as the lovable rogue emptied the show of two prize assets in my opinion. Firstly was the way quite interestingly, Mainwaring was prepared to get involved in black market activity. The other asset gone in my opinion which was the biggest loss was Walker being a constant thorn in the side of Mainwaring, interrupting his lectures with witty comments, thus leading to great comic rapport between Lowe and Beck. When he died, Welshman Taflyn Thomas was brought in as Private Cheeseman who was a journalist, having excelled in playing the role in a previous episode. In my view, Cheeseman was a decent character, but he simply wasn't strong enough to be lining up alongside Lowe, Le Mesurier, Dunn, Laurie, Ridley and Lavender. He was dropped after one series, a decision which was in my view a right one. It went on for two more series and continued to be excellent, yet not as good as say Series 4,5 and 6 where the show was quite clearly in its peak.'Dad's Army' lives on to be the only television programme which dates back to the 1960's that is still gets a prime time repeat on terrestrial television. According to the autobiography of sitcom writer Vince Powell, he had submitted an idea of a sitcom about the Home Guard to his superiors in 1968, his idea had just been beaten by Jimmy Perry. I say thank God for that. Powell's effort might have been decent, yet I doubt very much it would have been in the same league as Perry and Croft's effort and wouldn't be as strong today.'Dad's Army' will undoubtedly be remembered as a sitcom that brought laughter to many peoples lives. Long may its legacy live on.

selffamily I've seen Dad's Army over and over, so many episodes, and always enjoyed it. Have now just sat and watched series 1 which apparently I've not seen before (!) and laughed aloud. What brilliant timing, acting, writing, and story lines. Comedic genius, rare and precious, Perry and Croft do it over and over again, not only in Dad's Army but their others series (Hi de Hi is a particular favourite). I see that there are 9 series of Dad's Army, well I shall just have to sit and watch them all again. Did I mention that they are timeless? That too. Impossible to select a favourite character - they are all so polished and perfected. Using experienced and flawless actors helped of course.

bucksix I was a youngster during WW II living in America but I was made well aware of the courage and resolve of the British people. Dad's Army, in addition to being the best comedy show ever, shows us this courage. Unlike so many sit coms, it is not mean or vicious but is gentle yet over the top funny. Despite their bumbling and odd approach to things, their love of country, their braveness, and their willingness to die for England if they have to, always shows through.I own over 50 episodes on either VHS or DVD and am constantly searching for the ones I do not have. In addition I have both volumes of the complete scripts. I never get tired of watching or reading them. I can't watch the final episode (Never Too Old wherein Jonesy gets married and they drink a toast to the Home Guard every where)without feeling some tears welling up in my eyes. In fact, I'm starting to choke up a bit right now just thinking about it.I have acquaintances (notice I don't say friends) who have watched it with me and just don't get it. They prefer the smart Alex stuff which passes for humor today. I do feel sorry for them.