rupak_speaking People have issues with the climax of this otherwise very intriguing thriller, the precise reason it was a lesser hit of the Perfectionist Khan, but that aspect aside, it is a wonderful journey throughout. I thought the movie was perfectly cast. Aamir was his usual self, but on the acting front I would give it to Rani Mukherjee who did remarkably well. Kareena was at her glamorous best and extremely seductive at times when required (like the scene in the elevator with Aamir). Nawaz had an important role to play and did so with aplomb, yet again giving a gentle reminder to the industry that he is the ready to succeed Irfan. The music gelled very well with the mood of the film, and I kept humming the numbers for almost a week after. An 8/10...

Singh KP This movie is a lot like lost. It seems like it is building up to some epic conclusion, with a brilliant set up to the ending. It does a great job of setting up a murder mystery and keeping the viewer engaged with a decent plot. That is, a decent plot until the ending. When I was expecting some brilliant explanation to how the murders took place, all the film could come up with is BECAUSE GHOST. Sure that's fine for a horror film or a film based in some fantasy world with well defined parameters, but when a director bases his film as a murder mystery in the real physical world this is basically the worst cop out imaginable. The ending ruins the entire film. Not worth watching because of this.

vpspriyanath i saw the movie yesterday. until then i thought that this will be a amir khan's master pies like 3 idiots or tharee zameen per. but after watching this.. i was disappointed. script - The beginning is promising.But in the middle of the film, it feels like that writers wanted to keep the length of the film & wrote some useless scenes & dialog.i was so bored in the middle. conversation between kareena & amir was some times too long and boring. also i think that they've tried to complex the beginning & messed it. But depression & the loneliness of Amir khans was perfectly Written. no doubt about that.Acting - amir and rani was.... well... good. but not quiet Great.it's a role of typical police officer and even a normal actor can do it. but the loneliness and depressing part of Amir was well acted. kareena.. as always ( I believe) over acting.camera & edit - only thing in this movie i appreciate the most is camera and editing. it is very fascinating & shot composition is quiet Great. music support was medium. But this movie is not for Amhir. i expect more mature scripts from Ferhan Akthar like Dil chahatha hei. Anurag kaushep (Additional dialog) why did you sign up for this....?????

Shashi Nandivada As an Aamir Khan fan, I had to watch this movie!! And he did not disappoint as always.Story is good and believable, yes of course, the ending may not be acceptable, but you know, nothing is impossible!!!The characters, all of them have a role and that's a commendable part of the story!!!And yes, Kareena, she is the Queen of the movie...there could not be a Talaash without her!!!She is absolutely amazing in the movie, loved her totally, her style, her dialogue delivery, absolutely everything...Music is also very good, it stays with you for a long time after having watched the movie.Overall, a great watch!!