Dr Jacques COULARDEAU
This is a series that should make you shiver in your armchair, not of cold but of mental disruption, in other words, it will make you lose your mind. The idea is that everything is mathematical and everything can be reduced to statistical, numerical networks of equations and operations that dictate everything that may or might happen on this earth or in the universe. Welcome to an absolute Asperger autistic vision of life and the world. But if you neglect looking at the equations (they go too fast) or listening to the numbers and the theories that use all kinds of names for all kinds of arcane notions, every single one weirder than the previous or the next, you may survive the drowning bath they are trying to give you, to make you go through. Don't worry ressurection is guaranteed at the end of each episodeThen you will also be surprised by the fact that the three main characters are Jewish but so far from their religion that we hardly know about it. No Shabbat, no synagogue, no whatever could be in anyway Jewish. It must be mentioned less than a dozen times and a synagogue is actually visited twice. I guess in Los Angeles you can be a totally agnostic Jew with no problem at all.The third element is the triad of Eppes characters. The father has been a widower for a long time and his wife is only a recollection, a passing mention, an allusion, but no real presence, not even in a flashback of any sort. And she was supposed to be a very good mother. In fact, she must have been since the younger son, Charles was autistic, the Asperger savant type, and he was classified a genius by the age of fourteen and he got a Ph.D. when most people get their high school degree. And of course in mathematics. That makes him a rather simple autistic Asperger case. Mathematics and the capacity to see patterns everywhere and develop equations and theories to justify his intuition. His second autistic characteristic is his difficulty to have standard relationships with others that could be in any way more than dealing with numbers and I must say it took him five seasons to finally ask Amita to marry him. Some will, of course, tell me she was his student. For sure, but that did not prevent them from sleeping together long before getting married. It is just that he cannot establish a full emotional stable relationship with anyone, even his father and especially his elder brother who has become an FBI cop. Strangely enough in this family the young genius Charles is accepted and supported by mother (so they say), father and elder brother all the time, and Charles is not that keen on being intimate with his own brother and having a fair relationship with his father for a couple of season because he is living in his father's house.The point is that things start changing when the father wants to sell the house and buy a condo for himself to have a private personal life, and Charles, unknown of anyone, buys the house and becomes the landlord of his own father who accepts to stay and the house becomes a real commune, the three men of course, though the elder son seems to have an apartment somewhere though he does not have any stable relationship with anyone, woman or man. His life is an FBI caricature and for him, everyone is nothing but a partner, I mean a patrol partner.That leads this Don Eppes to propose his younger brother who is a professor of Applied Mathematics at the local university christened Cal-Sci, to become a consultant for the FBI with his mathematics. That changes the life of the younger brother who moves slightly loose in his teaching position and becomes more and more integrated into the FBI. In fact his autistic personality makes him become obsessive and compulsive in his onepointedness that becomes then catching crimimnals and even prebventing them from becoming criminals, and all that thanks to mathematics. Such changes in life are of course normal in many ways, not necessarily dramatic, and yet they are very dramatic indeed, at times tragic. But no matter how authoritarian he is in his attitude with everyone, he is absolutely not able to lead people and become what his elder brother is, the chief officer of a whole elite team of criminal cops. He can only be the prophet that shows the way but not the leader that goes down this way. He is an abstract mental roadsign and his brother is the leader of the pack of agents he takes to the crime scene or after the criminal Charles has pointed at.That then leads us to that elder son and brother who is a very good authoritative and respected chief officer, though inner affairs and trauma-psychiatrists are flabbergasted by his resistance and in fact predict he will sooner or later break down and lose his control over the crazy facts of criminal life. But he does not have the human dimension he could have in his own private life because he does not have a private life, even with the local District Attorney or Prosecutor.Amita Ramanujan is Indian and she came to Los Angeles as a student in computer science. She fell in love with her mathematics professor and her mathematics professor fell in love with his student, which was tricky as long as she was a student, though he made her his assistant as a graduate student preparing for a Ph.D. and when she got it she refused a position in some Eastern prestigious university to stay in this university where theory is not the objective but applied science is the norm. She will end up at the end of season five with Charles kneeling at her feet and proposing, finally proposing. And in the last season, the marriage is actually announced. For a Hindu girl she is extremely calm and Charles autism, Asperger in this case, does not seem to trouble her, to bother her. She just waits for him to move. She knows at least that much: you cannot force an autistic child to do anything that child does not want to do. You have to run with him and follow his inspiration. If you can swim through the numbers and the equations, knowing anyway that most of them must be fictitious, you might enjoy the action that is criminal for sure but with a light entertaining side to it, even when it is gross and full of blood. After all, it is only a TV story. I should, of course, quote a last perambulating erring character who is an applied physics professor Larry Fleinhardt but he is a dilettante. He spends six months in Space. He is always roaming around with a bit or piece of a theory, with some raspberries or other goodies, he even gets into Buddhism for a while and lives in a monastery, though he spends a lot of time in his own office turned into a den, or even underground in the sewers before finally accepting to be a perambulating lodger in Charles' house, though at first with great reluctance that I seem to think is slightly hypocritical, if not slightly more.I should, of course, get to the end of the series but I definitely must let you have something to discover by your own means. So enjoy your adventure.Dr. Jacques COULARDEAU
tkovacs-4
I really like this show. I like everything it promotes, I like the plots, I like the math, I like the camera work, I like...For a while I thought "at least they try to make the math plausible", unlike shows that just invent stuff on the spot. One day I saw an episode where Charlie and Amita "trace the flow of the Internet Protocol yada yada blah blah" in order to capture the bad guy. Finally being an expert on something they were depicting the realization hit me "they are BS us hard" (that much was obvious, but HARD was not to me). No matter how much Wolfram (the math behind numbers) tries to convince us the math is real the show changed forever for me.Charlie is a math genius. Amita is too. But they are *experts* in a lot of other stuff. For example in Computer Science, I've seen Charlie "do" some amazing things on this show, things that require years of dedication to CS, which I don't see how one could pull it off since he spent those years on math. Maybe they try to make the math plausible to a point, but they go all crazy with everything else, especially CS.In one episode Charlie actually cracks and hijacks servers of some criminals. In another Amita does programming like a pro, re-invents the whole damn Internet in 30 minutes. Amazing stuff, they are extreme programmers, network engineers, hackers, cryptographers, satellite communications experts... the list go on. What ever you need done Amita can pull it out of her sleeve because in her past life she was actually Alan Turing.
Ricardo FF Pontes (rffp)
After watching a dozen episodes, I decided to give up on this show since it depicts in an unrealistic manner what is mathematical modeling. In the episodes that Charlie would predict the future behavior of individuals using mathematical models, I thought that my profession was being joked about. I am not a mathematician, instead a chemical engineer, but I do work a lot with mathematical models. So I will try to explain to the layman why what is shown is close to "make-believe" of fairy tales.First, choosing the right model to predict a situation is a demanding task. Charlie Eppes is shown as a genius, but even him would have to spend considerable time researching for a suitable model, specifically for trying to guess what someone will do or where he will be in the near future. Individuals are erratic and haphazard, there is no modeling for them. Isaac Asimov even wrote about that in the 1950's. Even if there were a model for specific kind of individual, it would be a probabilistic (stoichastic) one, meaning it has good chance of making a wrong prediction.Second, supposing the right model for someone or a situation is found, the model parameters have to be known. These parameters are the constants of the equations, such as the gravity acceleration (9.8 m/s2), and often are not easy to determine. Again, Charlie Eppes would have to be someone beyond genius to know the right parameters for the model he chooses. And after the model and the parameters are chosen, they would have to be tested. Oddly, they are not, and by miracle, they fit exactly the situation that is being predicted.Third, a very important aspect of modeling is almost always neglected, not only by Numbers, but also by sci-fi movies: the computational effort required for solving these models. Try to make Excel solve a complex model with many equations and variables and one will find doing a Herculean job. Even if Charlie Eppes has the right software to solve his models, he might be stuck with hardware that will be dreadfully slow. And even with the right software/hardware combination, the model solution might well take days to be reached. He solves them immediately! I could use his computer in my research work, I would be very glad.As a drama, it is far from being the best show. The characters are somewhat stereotyped, but not even remotely funny as those in Big Bang Theory are. The crimes are dull and the way Charlie Eppes solves them sometimes make the FBI look pretty incompetent.For some layman, the show might work. For others, the way things are handled makes it difficult to swallow!
