charitymama This is one of the greatest shows ever. Great cast and great stories. I watch these episodes over and over again all the time.

Jack It was among the best TV show at the time. It was very good at the time. If you like to fantasize about witchcraft and magic, I haven't found any other contemporary TV shows or movies as good as Charmed. It was legendary for this genre. If they make a remake of Charmed it would be exciting as the original was not in HD format.

Alphareign I used to love this show, but unfortunately, the character Piper ruined it for me. She is a bitch. Also, the magic school nonsense made it even worse. To add insult to injury was the character Billie. Piper should have died and left Prue, Phoebe, and eventually Paige.Charmeds storyline was good and relatively unique. The shows dramatic and comedic elements were both well developed and they balanced each other nicely.Set design was lovely; especially for the inside of the "Halliwell Manor". As a fan of Victorian architecture, I have to say that it was quite lovely. "P3" also had a nice set design and looked as I imagine a decent modern night-club would. Other sets did not play a big enough role to comment on.The acting was amazing. Even though I do not like her character, Holly Marie Combs did a fantastic job portraying Piper Halliwell. Of course, all of the actors did a fantastic job. The choice of guest actors was delightfully surprising especially since Charmed had Victor Webster.

jrobkal So all in all this was a big episode, because in this Andy finally ( although he practically already knew ) saw for himself Prue's ability. Going forward this will and did impact the rest of the season, and maybe detective Trudeau will assist the sisters in their future endeavors. Now I know, though I have not seen yet, that Andy does not quite make it to season 2. Yet maybe he and Prue will still mend some trace of their past and come to term with something. Aside from that it was a great premise for an episode, and wow I forgot about the reporter who witnessed prue's actions and threatened to expose them to the world. That was also a fantastic addition to the episode. 10 out of 10 for me.