zee
Far better than the half-dozen network TV shows that try to show a post- apocalyptic world, this is still not perfectly imagined.Here's the central premise: a plague has wiped out everyone over the age of puberty, all at once, leaving children 0-12 to find their own way. 15 years later, they've done amazingly well. I suspect there'd be a little more Lord of the Flies behaviors in such a situation, but here, not only are the people reasonably happy and well-adjusted, everything in this world looks organized, only mildly dirty, and fairly well engineered.Moreover, the casting and the stories keep forgetting the central premise. Luke Perry looks 40-something (he wasn't quite that at filming but looks older), yet the oldest person alive should be 27, and no way can he pass for that. One can imagine that almost none of the infants alive at the time of the plague would have survived (having only traumatized orphans to find and mince food for them), so people from the old times should be 17-27 and their post-plague children 0-12. But clearly older actors abound and you'll get a plot where a stated 16- year-old has a father. Huh?Plot-wise, good (if damaged) guy Perry and his sidekick (whose personality shifts about in season 1) meander around in a surviving automobile, never running out of gas, and which they seem to know how to drive at once without any chance for training at that skill, and they have episodic adventures that reminded me of the old Incredible Hulk and Fugitive series. (Guy arrives at new town each week, meets someone with a problem, helps him or her solve it in 45 minutes of screen time, drives off into sunset at end of show.) There's an overarching narrative, too, involving various groups trying to set themselves up to rule a greater number of people, but mostly this episodic plot, developing an emotional connection for the leads to a girl or child, and after someone has made the Big Speech, the leads drive off into the sunset. While that's not original, it is an appropriate choice for a P-A series, as it gives us a chance to look at how various dystopic groups that may have formed. It would have been interesting had they occasionally driven into town, mis-assessed the situation, and hurt more than helped, but the show's writers played it safe and kept to the formula.For a world in which technology is dying and the knowledge needed to keep it going mostly forgotten, it sure keeps popping up a lot. Cars, gasoline, bullets, helicopters, running water, short-wave radios, whatever a plot needs, the tech is there, but precious little time is spent suggesting that there are people working at figuring these things out and keeping tech working. Admittedly, that's not very exciting stuff to show, but an occasional added reference would make the wider world more believable, as would more awe from the natives at their arriving in a working car. Nor do you see a lot of farming, which would be what 99% of people do 99% of the time. Still, it is far less cloying and unrealistic than the networks' attempts at PA stories, and it's pleasant to hear cursing, frank talk about sex, and even some atheism (without growing up with religious training, surely most people wouldn't be). And the leads are almost always wearing the same clothes and don't look overly well-scrubbed, for which I give points.I got bored so didn't watch the second season; this is a review of the first season only.
royalef
The show had promise and built the characters reasonably and set a consistent atmosphere. I watched both seasons on Netflix long after it was canceled. The first season is very enjoyable, but I found much of the second season... unwatchable. The show became plagued by very preachy, stunted dialogue, bad scenes and smash you over the head with our message subtly.Straczinsky has publicly commented on how bad his experience was with MGM during the second season, saying he "got the hell out of there." His loss of control was obvious throughout the 2nd season, particularly in the quality of the writing and plots. There is an episode in which there is a verrrry long monologue voice over. I believe it may have lasted 2-3 minutes--it felt like it. It just goes on and on. Literally it stopped me and I said to the screen, "what the hell?" I was so disappointed by the second season. The show went off the rails. Definitely watch the first season, but lower expectations for the second.
bperdew98
Although there are reasons that make this series not perfect, it shows a very humanistic view on the treatment of people and life. Based on graphic novels not really know by many, being from Europe, a lot of Americans don't know the source material. The actors do a great job and portray characters with faults, obsessions and desires. Sometimes cheesy but always developing the story I would recommend it to anyone especially the second season the story arcs pick up more meaning, and get more serious. I would suggest the series to anyone with a hope for society beyond the brutality inferred by other literature. Most of the actors do a great job creating characters that draw you into caring about the person even Lee who is pretty much an A-hole. It bridges a lot with life, religion and faith.
