evening1 Interesting and compelling depiction of a sordid crime from the early Nineties that provided lots of fodder for the tabloids. Jack Scalia is excellent as Joey Buttafuoco. Alyssa Milano is scary as the obsessive seductress Amy Fisher, and Phyllis Lyons is superb -- showing impressive range as Joey's blameless and beleaguered wife, Mary Jo. Also very good is Lawrence Tierney in the small role of Joey's frustrated father. This TV movie attempts to show how the relationship between Joey and Amy wrecked all manor of havoc. The director shows us people who don't put much thought into the consequences of their actions. They live for the moment with a lot of emotional fireworks -- the effects on their loved ones be damned. One flaw in the film is its haziness as to the motivation of Amy, who apparently was already involved with a new married boyfriend at the time she shot Mary Jo in the head. As long as LMN is showing this 20- year-old film, it should add a written epilogue to complete the story.According to Wikipedia, Joey -- who in the movie consistently denies he ever had sex with Amy -- ended up serving four months for statutory rape. Mary Jo worked toward securing an earlier release for Amy -- she'd been sentenced to 15 years -- and filed for divorce.It had all begun when Amy drove her dented car into Joey's body shop. This riveting film is a reminder of how a chance encounter can lead to mayhem.

Horrorible_Horror_Films Wow, this is wicked awesome. I was sitting around this Saturday afternoon, looking for something to watch and Lo and Behold "Long Island Lolita Story" appears on the TV. On the Lifetime network - of course! This is the same channel I've seen such classics as "No One Would Tell" starring Kevin Arnold and DJ Tanner and "Unwed Father" starring David Silver from the original 90210.Anyway, its clear Joey Buttafuoco was totally 100% innocent. I mean sure...he actually pled guilty to statutory rape, and in the ensuing years he's been arrested for fraud and solicitation of hookers, so you see, he's just a real nice guy that just was hit on by a slutty long island Lolita, he never slept with her or did anything wrong! Watch this movie any chance you get!

marbleann I live on Long Island and at the time the next town over from Amy Fisher. THis is what was going around after this came down. First is the only reason this case became so popular even before the trial or anything was know about the characters involved it because the press was at the scene as son as it happened. Not the usual amount of press but big time press WHy? Because the Buttafucoes lived on the same block of a Mafia associate and they thought the shooting happened at his resident..thus all the press coverage. Secondly I remember Mary Joe being in big time denial about her husband. Her mother even said she wished she had married a man as good as Joey. She actually lost a lot of sympathy because of that. People saw Joey and Amy together all of the time. He made no secret of the affair. He even took his kids with them on a few outings. Whatever the case the man was to old to be dealing with a confused teenager. there was no doubt where I lived he was sleeping with her and leading her on. His family's auto body place was on the corner of Grand Ave. and Merrick rd A major street in Baldwin. I passed it a million times but never paid attention to it until the shooting. After that people would drive to that corner just to get a glance of Joey. He actually became a minor celeb on Long Island. This did not help his case,because he was real cocky people thought he should of gotten locked up because he had to have something to do with the shooting. That was always out there. We knew Amy was fast but the guys were always men who were too old for her. She had a lot of family problems. I always felt very bad for her mother. She seemed to have gone through a lot. People would go to the motels they went to and try to stay in the rooms they stayed in. It was a joke. In any case Amy shot his wife and she was wrong but he should of went to jail too. Now on to the movie. Jack Scalia is a very good looking slim Joey. believe me the real life Joey was not a looker. He plays him as a man who was stalked by this teenager, and never touched her. Well we all know that was not true because motel clerks/receipts attested to the opposite. he should of known better. Allyssa Milano plays a very good looking Amy. Amy by no means was a Fox is portrayed as a predatory sex fiend. She was fast but not without Joeys help. The woman who plays Mary Jo is the truest role on the movie, she sounds and looks just like Mary Jo. THe location of the movie is not Long Island and it doesn't come close. One scene Joey is at a carnival and asks Amy why came so far. Well Massapequa is only around 15 minutes away from Merrick. THese are all south shore towns and Sunrise Hwy goes right through them all. And Merick is only 4 towns away. So the dialog couldn't even get the locations right. I figure at least get the area correct. Amy went to jail and she should of. Joey and Mary Jo moved to California he actually thought he could get into the movie business. The auto body shop which had been there for years closed down...very sad. Amy is out of jail now and she has a newspaper column which is very good. the Buttofucco's are divorced. Mary Jo seems to reconciled to the fact her hubby was not all innocent. But what is more interesting is that she has forgiven AMy which I thought would never happened. I really think Mary Jo is a strong woman now. What they should do is make a movie about the incident now, it is a true American Tragedy, but in the end things seem to turn out OK. This movie was rushed just like the other Amy Fisher movies and it shows. I liked that Lawrence Tierney plays the dd another very sympathetic person in this whole mess. Like Amy's mother he seemed like the whole world was on his shoulder and his auto body shop closed down.

Robert J. Maxwell A depressing tale of a middle-aged man and teen-aged girl who have an affair, presumably, after which the girl shoots the guy's wife in the head, so that the girl and the guy can get married, or at least live together, happily ever after. It's based on the real events surrounding Aimee Fisher and Joey Buttafuco. She's played my Alyssa Milano, in probably her most demanding role, and the car mechanic is Jack Scalia. What a tawdry tale. A narcissistic pedophile and a spoiled pretty nymphomaniac. Lots of sex, intrigue, conflict, some violence, all rather disgusting, which is probably why three independent TV made-for movies about the case hit the TV screens at the same time. This one is definitely from Butaffuco's point of view. The poor guy loves his wife and children (sob) and never touches this succulent nymphet. Fisher is plumply overdeveloped, more than simply enticing, bursting her seams, and she's the aggressor and the liar in the tale. Buttafuco is the innocent victim. Right. No ex coke addicted, pumped up, self-admiring Italian philanderer would dream of laying a paw on this fawning young creature. Man, is he put upon. Our eyes water at the narrative. Aimee lies to her family and tells them that Joey gave her herpes. Then tries to murder his wife. And all this time he's nothing more than a cheerful, loving, family man and upright citizen, aghast at all the terrible things he's accused of. Did he fund this movie? The other two made-fors took quite different points of view, depending on who was backing the production and which particular participant in this disgusting tale was doing the endoresements. Utterly revolting garbage, which the public ate up. Alyssa Milano is a beautiful young woman. Anyone who wants to see her en deshabille should rent "Kiss of the Vampire" or whatever it was, far sexier, and less repugnant simply because it is more mindless. This movie actually has a point of view. It could have skipped the sleazy plot and just shown us Joey pumping iron in a gym and Aimee coupling in some stranger's back seat. An insult to the public viewer, who gobbled it down with relish.